BigCommerce vs Magento: Side-by-side Comparison in 2024

Are you confused between BigCommerce vs Magento? Between Magento and Bigcommerce, which platform is the best platform for your eCommerce website? or Calculating the pros and cons of Bigcommerce vs Magento then this blog will give you answers to all your queries related to Magento and BigCommerce.

BigCommerce and Magento both are giant names in their eCommerce market and you know these all have a huge audience rate in the eCommerce world. Therefore, selecting between BigCommerce vs Magento is a hard task.

You can take some major points that every eCommerce website needs to have on its website. And analyze Magento and BigCommerce on these parameters to know which one is best for you.  

While developing the best eCommerce website for your business you need to be careful. This selection is not just for the initial stage of your eCommerce business but also it’s a future strategy that you need to take. 

In this blog, you know all the major pros and cons of your website to help you in selecting the best platform between BigCommerce vs Magento. So let’s start.

Quick Comparison Between BigCommerce vs Magento

Get to Know All Pros and Cons of BigCommerce vs Magento

Many factors are good in Magento and some good points in BigCommerce. Read all the pros and cons of BigCommerce vs Magento to know the best platform for your eCommerce website. 

Easy to Use: BigCommerce vs Magento

eCommerce business owners have to manage various tasks such as development. The store owners have a lot on their minds, from designing a brand strategy to testing new products, and they don’t want to waste so much time on their website.

A platform with a clean and easy-to-use backend interface helps them complete tasks quickly and focus on other important things. So usability is a major factor that you should check before selecting the eCommerce platform.

Magento requires IT knowledge to set up a new store from source code. These tasks include setting up an FTP file, integrating the store theme into your Magento website, and so on.

In addition, it is difficult for non-tech-savvy users to make any further changes to their Magento website as the tasks also involve coding knowledge.

These include theme customization, extension integration, security patch uploads, speed optimization, and more. Therefore, many store owners have to rely on a Magento expert to develop and maintain their Magento website.

However, once the initial technical setup is done, users can easily customize the attributes and features for their website in the Magento backend. The interface is quite intuitive even for beginners. Adding products, creating customer groups, setting currencies and more can be done easily.

Last but not least, Magento users have to find a suitable hosting solution and manage it all by themselves, which can take more time and effort.

On the other hand, Bigcommerce makes it much more enjoyable for non-technical store owners to build their eCommerce websites.

No technical installation is required to fill in simple information to access your BigCommerce dashboard. You can easily configure and manage all aspects of your store, from importing products to changing your page layout.

BigCommerce includes a drag-and-drop page builder so you can easily create a stunning storefront without writing a single line of code.

Plus, themes and extensions can be easily added with just a few clicks. Hosting is also included in the package.

Verdict

As we can see, both platforms have an easy-to-use backend interface for management activities. While the initial process of installing and customizing a Magento website requires coding. On the other side, BigCommerce allows users to do all these jobs without any technical skills.

Performance and Security: BigCommerce vs Magento

In the eCommerce industry, you have to put so much rich media on websites and rich media makes your website hard to load. Nowadays, people are so busy and they want information instantly.

If your site is not enough to load quickly, then your visitors switch your site. In the same way, website security also plays a major role in building credibility and growing your customers. Hence, speed and security are major factors for growing your online business. So, we examine BigCommerce vs Magento in this parameter.

With Progressive Web App on Magento, you can build a high-speed website with an advanced user experience. On the other hand, Bigcommerce hosted eCommerce platform guarantees to provide 99.99% uptime website performance. Apart from this, Google AMP Integration provides you with speedy mobile pages. 

In terms of security, Magento provides Secure URLs, two-factor authentication, frequent security patches, and back up to make your site risk-free. So, you can assure yourself from the Magento side for security. When we talk about BigCommerce then it provides dedicated SSL certificates, intrusion detection, backups, and a firewall. Make your site secure. 

Verdict

As we can see both platforms keep in mind all major factors of performance and security by providing so many facilities to enhance your security and user experience.

Popularity: BigCommerce vs Magento

The eCommerce platform’s popularity partly reflects its capabilities and reliability. While both Magento and BigCommerce are the top choices among eCommerce business owners, there is still a gap between their user numbers.

According to Mageworx.com: these famous brands like Helly Hansen, Sigma Beauty, Ford, Liverpool, Landrover, Nestle Nespresso, etc. are using Magento as their website builder. Apart from these brands currently, there are more than 162,787  Magento sites that are active. 

On the other hand, the BigCommerce platform has currently 49,712 live websites including some famous brands that use BigCommerce: Sony, Ford, Airtasker, Bulk Apothecary, Casio, RAZER, etc. 

Verdict

In terms of popularity, Magento is the winner of this challenge between Magento vs BigCommerce. Because Magento has a larger number of users as compared to Bigcommerce.

Scalability: BigCommerce vs Magento

In the eCommerce sector, scalability is a very important factor. These features refer to the platform’s ability to maintain performance and efficiency as your business grows. Huge e-commerce sites need to process a lot of resources and data daily. 

Therefore, to fulfill these requirements more powerful hosting plans and specialized maintenance.

Magento and BigCommerce can handle enterprise-level sales and traffic. But Magento is better for scalable businesses because Magento doesn’t have a sales threshold, while BigCommerce would require you to upgrade to a larger plan once you reach a certain annual income.

These prices are distributed according to your sale: such as, if your sales are up to $50,000/year then you have to pay $29.95/month as a standard price. Apart from the standard price, BigCommerce offers plus, pro, and enterprise packages. 

To get details about the price you can check their official site. I also mention the price details down below in the blog. So, read on. 

Verdict

You can easily expand your store in Magento as compared to BigCommerce without any additional cost. Thus, the winner is Magento.

Customization: BigCommerce vs Magento

To make unique site customization is the only way to modify your website. You can modify any of the core built-in features, extensions, and themes to suit a website’s specific needs.

So, you need an e-commerce platform with high customization functionality. Let’s see the result of Magento vs Bigcommerce on the customization parameter. 

As a free open-source platform, Magento allows developers to access the source code free of cost, which means you can do unlimited customization on your website.

On the other hand, BigCommerce is a SaaS platform that restricts any backend intervention. You can customize some details in the front end by using some codes like Javascript.

Verdict

As you can see, Magento offers a full customization facility, whereas BigCommerce does not allow such kind of customization. So, in this parameter the winner is Magento. 

Built-in features: BigCommerce vs Magento

BigCommerce is the best choice for payment options. The eCommerce platform connects with more than 65 major payment solution providers, including mobile wallets such as Apple Pay and Google Pay. You also don’t have to pay any transaction fees to use these services.

When it comes to offline payments, BigCommerce supports a wide range of methods from checks and bank deposits to cash and cash on delivery.

However, Magento only supports Paypal and Authorize.net by default. So if you want to use another third-party payment, you have to rely on the extension.

The platform does not charge you any fees, but you may have to pay some processing fees depending on the payment providers.

On the offline end, Magento offers the same benefits as BigCommerce, plus the ability to accept orders. This is suitable for businesses whose each order is often of high value or high volume.

In short, both Magento and BigCommerce offer amazing options. While Magento is better for managing multiple stores and promoting on-site, BigCommerce makes it easy to integrate with various sales channels and payment gateways.

Verdict

Both platforms offer an excellent series of built-in features. So, it’s a tie match between Magento vs Bigcommerce. 

Themes and Extensions: BigCommerce vs Magento

Apart from built-in features, themes and extensions are two other crucial factors that make your digital store powerful. The wide availability and high quality of templates and plugins will allow you to customize your website conveniently. As a result, you can create a unique website that is optimized to support the sales of your business.

Just by browsing the BigCommerce and Magento marketplaces, you’ll find plenty of opportunities to upgrade your eCommerce store, from improving your SEO in minutes to turning it into a professional B2B website.

When we talk about Magento then you get 3053+ extensions and 5 themes on the official Magento Marketplace. Here are 825 extensions and 3 themes are available for free to use. Apart from this, you can also add themes from Themeforest. They have more than 394 themes for Magento eCommerce. 

On the other site, Bigcommerce offers 305 themes and 1181 extensions are available on the official site. There are 12 free themes and some free extensions are available. 

Verdict

In terms of themes and extensions, Magento has a large gallery as compared to BigCommerce. So, the winner is Magento.

Price: BigCommerce vs Magento

Pricing plays a lead role in your eCommerce business setup. What you can afford depends on your budget. So we should discuss this parameter to know the real potential and efficiency. 

So let’s first talk about BigCommerce, as a SaaS platform you have to pay some amount recurring. You can choose your plan on a monthly or yearly payment basis according to your budget.

In Bigcommerce, once you reach a sale threshold, you have to upgrade your plan and choose a higher one. Here are the plan details of BigCommerce. 

1. Standard plan $29.95/month for your yearly online sales to reach up to $50k.
2. Plus plan $79.95/month for yearly online sales reach up to $180k.
3. Pro plan $299.95/month for your yearly online sales to reach up to $400k
4. Enterprise plan is the custom build plan that any company can contact and make a deal with. 

These plans include the cost of hosting and domain name with e-commerce management features. 

If you want to use customized or paid templates and plugins then you have to pay the following additional charges. 

The theme on its official app store cost $195 to $300 and from ThemeForest, it costs around $60 to $200. In addition, plugins on the official app store charge between $9 to $90/month. 

Now, let’s discuss the Magento prices. 

While the Commercial version of Magento is 100% free of cost but to build a Fully functional website you need to hire a Magento developer. Moreover, the cost of building a fully functional website they charge between $4000- $5000. This price depends upon your requirements. This is a one-time expense that you have to pay at the beginning of your business project. 

In addition, the cost of hosting and the domain is around $15 to $110/monthly. If you want a customized Magento Extension then it costs around $70 to $400 for a lifetime license, and a paid theme would cost you from $80 to $160. But you can reduce this cost by using free themes and extensions. 

Verdict

If you are planning for a giant eCommerce business with a huge budget then you can go with Magento but if you are a small startup then you should go with Bigcommerce. 

In general, Bigcommerce is the clear winner for the pricing parameter. 

Final Words

In the war between Bigcommerce vs Magento, there are lots of good factors between Magento and Bigcommerce. They have their pros and cons. So you need to analyze your business and pick the perfect match for your eCommerce requirements.

If you are not clear about which platform you have to choose, then you can take a free consultation from the Magento eCommerce development agency Pixlogix Infotech. 

Pixlogix Infotech is the best eCommerce website developers company that offers various eCommerce solutions for Magento, WordPress, Prestashop, Shopify, and many more. So, they can help you by providing the exact solution for your requirement. Book your free consultation now.